"I thought I needed a home health aide, but I was really just struggling with household chores and minor repairs," shares Dorothy, 83. "Understanding the difference saved me over $1,500 monthly and still got me exactly the help I needed."
In this guide, we'll clarify the distinct roles of homemakers, handymen, and home health aides, helping you determine which service—or combination of services—best addresses your specific needs while optimizing your care budget.
Before deciding which service is right for you or your loved one, it's essential to understand what each professional does, their typical costs, and when they're most appropriate.
What Homemaker Services Include:
When Homemaker Services Are Ideal:Homemaker services are the right choice when the primary challenge is keeping up with household tasks, not personal care or health management. They're perfect for seniors who:
Average Cost: $35-45 per hour, typically with minimum visit requirements of 4 hours
"My homemaker comes twice weekly for 4 hours each visit. She handles all the housework I can no longer do and prepares several meals I can easily reheat. It's made a world of difference."
- James, 78
What Handyman Services Include:
When Handyman Services Are Ideal:Handyman services address specific home maintenance and safety needs. They're most appropriate when:
Average Cost: $60-125 per hour, often with minimum fees or service calls
"After my fall, my son hired a handyman who specialized in senior safety. He installed grab bars, secured rugs, improved lighting, and fixed several small issues I'd been ignoring. I feel so much safer now." - Barbara, 85
What Home Health Aide Services Include:
When Home Health Aide Services Are Ideal:Home health aides provide personal care and basic medical support under professional supervision. They're necessary when:
Average Cost: $35-50 per hour, often available through Medicare if prescribed by a physician
"After my stroke, I needed help with bathing and dressing. My home health aide visits every morning to help me start my day, checks my blood pressure, and ensures I take my medications correctly." - Thomas, 76
Many families struggle to determine which service is truly needed. Use this self-assessment to clarify your situation:
✓ Is keeping the house clean becoming difficult?
✓ Is laundry piling up or being neglected?
✓ Has meal preparation become challenging or overwhelming?
✓ Are errands and grocery shopping becoming stressful?
✓ Is household organization deteriorating?
If you checked 3+ items: Homemaker services would likely address your primary concerns.
✓ Are there minor repairs needed around the home?
✓ Do seasonal tasks like gutter cleaning or weatherproofing seem daunting?
✓ Are there safety concerns that require modifications (loose railings, poor lighting)?
✓ Has yard maintenance become too physically demanding?
✓ Are appliances or fixtures malfunctioning?
If you checked 3+ items: Handyman services focused on senior safety would be beneficial.
✓ Is bathing or showering becoming difficult or risky?
✓ Is dressing or undressing a daily struggle?
✓ Is managing multiple medications complicated or confusing?
✓ Are prescribed exercises difficult to perform independently?
✓ Is monitoring health conditions (blood pressure, blood sugar) challenging?
If you checked 3+ items: Home health aide services may be necessary.
One of the most frequent mistakes families make is selecting a higher level of care than actually needed, resulting in unnecessary expenses and potential loss of independence.
Many seniors discover that no single service completely addresses their needs. Creating a customized care plan often provides the most effective and economical solution.
Homemaker + Occasional HandymanThis pairing works well for seniors who primarily need household help but also require periodic home maintenance.
Home Health Aide + Homemaker
This combination is ideal when medical needs require professional attention, but household tasks still need managing.
All Three Services on Different Schedules
Some seniors benefit from a comprehensive approach:
While traditional service providers offer valuable assistance, an innovative alternative is emerging that can address multiple needs simultaneously: home sharing.
Home sharing, like the model offered by Home Sweet Homeshare, pairs older homeowners with vetted houseguests who provide both homemaker assistance and basic handyman services in exchange for reduced rent.
This arrangement can:
For seniors who primarily need household management and basic maintenance rather than medical care, home sharing can offer a more economical and comprehensive solution than hiring separate services.
"I was spending over $1,200 monthly on homemaker visits and handyman services. Through home sharing, I now receive more consistent help and earn $750 monthly instead. It's completely transformed my retirement finances." - Eleanor, 84
Determining which service—or combination of services—best meets your needs involves several important steps:
Before contacting any service providers:
Different services have different payment structures and potential coverage:
Once you've identified your needs:
Choosing between homemaker services, handyman assistance, and home health aides—or creating a combination approach—can significantly impact both quality of life and financial wellbeing for seniors aging in place.
By accurately identifying your true needs and matching them to the appropriate services, you can ensure you're receiving exactly the support required without overpaying for unnecessary assistance. For many seniors, this thoughtful approach makes the difference between struggling at home and thriving with just the right level of support.
If you remain uncertain about which service aligns best with your needs, Home Sweet Homeshare provides complimentary consultations. These sessions are designed to evaluate your unique situation and determine whether traditional services or innovative solutions like home sharing are more suitable for your specific requirements.
Schedule Your Free Consultation →